Credit Laura McDermott for The New York Times
Successful sellers on eBay know certain things matter: item description, appealing photos, strong seller ratings and, of course, price.
Now, a study published Friday in the journal Science suggested another factor might make a subtle difference: whether the seller is a man or woman. Using data supplied by the company, researchers analyzed some 630,000 auction transactions on eBay in the United States and reported that, on average, when men and women with equal selling reputations sold the same products, women received lower prices than men.
The difference was far less pronounced for used items: Women sellers received about 97 cents for every dollar men received. But with new items, where the authors say direct comparison is easier, women received about 80 cents on average for every dollar men sellers received.
Economic View: How to Bridge That Stubborn Pay GapJAN. 15, 2016
Gender Gap: Even Famous Female Economists Get No RespectNOV. 11, 2015
Jennifer Lawrence Speaks Out Against Gender Pay InequalityOCT. 13, 2015
Well: Stubborn Pay Gap Is Found in NursingMARCH 24, 2015
Your Money: Vigilant Eye on Gender Pay Gap NOV. 14, 2014
Women’s Wages: Pay Gap Is Smaller Than Ever, and Still Stubbornly LargeSEPT. 17, 2014
The Upshot : Pay Gap Is Because of Gender, Not JobsAPRIL 23, 2014
Economic View: Possible Path to Closing Pay GapMAY 10, 2014
âThe basic point â that people have different expectations of women versus men and so we treat them very differently in the world â itâs fascinating and depressing,â said Linda Babcock, an economics professor at Carnegie Mellon University, who was not involved in the study.
âOn eBay, wow,â she added, noting eBayâs fame as a forum where anyone can sell anything. It also does not require that sellers identify their gender. âThis would be kind of the best example where you would think that discrimination would be at its smallest. So we can interpret these data as a lower bound of what we can expect in other environments.â
The study did not paint a universally negative picture for women. For some items, like toys and pet products, women received somewhat higher prices than men. And women tended to have better reputations as sellers, although they tended to have less selling experience.
Nor did the study, which controlled for seller reputation, experience, number of photos, use of bold lettering and other elements, indicate that buyers were actively or even consciously discriminating. Male and female buyers appeared to treat women sellers the same, the authors said.
âWe actually think that most of it is unconscious,â said Tamar Kricheli-Katz, a professor of law and sociology at Tel Aviv University, who conducted the study with Tali Regev, an economist at IDC Herzliya. âThe fact is that most of us have biases. We hold them unconsciously, and it makes it difficult to change.â
Besides analyzing actual eBay transactions, the researchers conducted an experiment to see if people could tell the gender of sellers from user profiles. People guessed correctly in 1,127 of 2,000 cases, wrong in 170 and did not know the rest.
In another experiment, the researchers asked people to place value on a $ 100 Amazon gift card sold by someone named either Alison or Brad. On average, Alisonâs gift card was valued at $ 83.34, while Bradâs was valued at $ 87.42.
Claudia Goldin, a Harvard economist and expert on gender wage gaps, said the study was intriguing but needed more analysis. âJust perceiving that somebodyâs a woman, what exactly does it mean?â she asked. âItâs got to mean something about the quality of the good or service or something thatâs not captured in the data that they have.â
Without that additional information, Dr. Goldin said her hunch is that âthe majority of people would be bidding less if they thought that, âThis really isnât a 1948 Rolexâ or âThis really isnât Jackie Robinsonâs signature.â â
The researchers said eBay allowed them access to data on transactions, sellers and buyers, including gender. They evaluated transactions from 2009 to 2012, focusing on the 420 most popular items in eBayâs broader categories, and on auctions because no negotiation is involved. Sellers considered to be stores were excluded.
EBay did not provide financing for the study, but set conditions, according to the authors and to editors at Science. The researchersâ contract allowed eBay to approve any study before publication, mostly for potential disclosure of proprietary data and trade secrets; the authors said eBay âended up approving the study without asking us to drop any of our results.â
EBay declined to discuss the specifics of the study with a reporter. In a statement, the company did not challenge the results. âThis study, which was based on data from more than four years ago, was not conducted or commissioned by eBay,â the statement said, adding, âWe are passionate about harnessing our platform to empower millions of people by leveling the playing field for them. We do not reveal the gender of our sellers, although they can choose to do that themselves.â
Because the study computed averages, the experience of individual sellers might not match the trend, experts said. Indeed, when The New York Times, in reporting about the study, asked on Facebook if women eBay sellers felt that gender helped or hurt their sales, many people who posted responses said they felt gender was a nonissue on eBay.
âPrice, shipping, description â¦ thatâs what eBay buyers worry about,â wrote Susan Butler Carpenter, a former banker who is now a stay-at-home mother in Pennsylvania and an eBay seller for 16 years. âAnyone who says their gender as a woman has hurt or helped their sales is full of it. Why look for an issue where there is none?â
A few female sellers said they believed some buyers reacted differently because they were women.
Melanie Fodera, 21, a senior at Albion College in Michigan and a seller for about seven years, said when selling a Detroit Lions jersey for â$ 100 or best offer,â she was offered $ 50.
âI countered $ 75, and their message to me was, âYou donât know what this is worth because youâre a girl,â â said Ms. Fodera, who usually sells womenâs clothes and has an eBay page decorated with roses.
Another Facebook commenter, Justina Gilliam, posted: âIt all depends on what Iâm selling, really. I donât sell often, but Iâve gotten men who think they can take advantage when I list sports tickets/memorabilia and women who get upset if I canât answer intricate details about a LladrÃ³ that was given to me but Iâm getting rid of because I donât care for it.â
In the 631,516 auctions the authors analyzed, women were about 23 percent of sellers. They received, on average, 0.88 fewer bids for the same items, the authors said. New items, where researchers found the largest gender gap, accounted for 78,350 sales. The biggest advantage for male sellers occurred in categories like new video games (the gap was especially huge for Nintendo Wii).
The authors analyzed the text sellers used, finding that women used slightly more positive language, saying âworks greatâ more often than ânever used,â for example, Dr. Regev said. But wording differences did not account for the price gap.
Cecilia Ridgeway, a gender issues expert at Stanford, said when reading the study, âI did not think, âOh, eBay needs to fix this.â I donât think this is a key thing weâve got to do for gender equality.â
Still, she said she viewed the study as an indicator of âthe importance of gender as a way of making sense of any human being. That doesnât mean people endorse these beliefs; they just know them.â